In that last month of pregnancy, strangers asked me the same questions on repeat: When was I due? How was I feeling? Did I know what I was having? I didn’t mind this. What I did mind was the track that conversation sometimes veered onto after I answered that last question with, “A girl!” Some people gave answers that warmed my overworked heart: “Oh, four girls! How sweet!” or “I’m one of four sisters! It is so much fun.” But sometimes the answers were less heart-warming:
“Just wait until they’re teenagers.”
“Oh well—keep trying for that boy!”
“Your poor husband!”
A much smaller, fully rested me would laugh those comments off. But at nine months pregnant, there were hormones involved; I couldn’t even pretend that the comments were funny. I knew we were excited about life with four daughters and that we weren’t “trying for a boy,” but I was too tired to explain that again and again to strangers in the bulk food aisle.

So I came up with a parry that redirected that conversation into safer, more joyful, more literary waters. Here’s how it worked:
Well-meaning stranger in the check-out line: “Do you know what you’re having?”
Me: “A girl!”
Stranger peers over my shoulder, obviously counting the daughters trailing behind me like ducklings, and raises her eyebrows. But before she can comment, I finish, ” . . . and we’re reading Little Women to celebrate!”
Her eyebrows drop and the stranger smiles. “I loved that book when I was a little girl!” And just like that, we’ve left off discussing monthly cycles and man caves, and started discussing, instead, our favorite March sisters.

Set during the Civil War, the story of the March family recounts the adventures of four sisters—sweet Meg, unconventional Jo, gentle Beth, and precocious Amy—as they help their mother hold down the fort while their father is away fighting in the Union army. The Marches are one of the literary families who seem to belong to the reader: their home began to feel like home as we read, their struggles began to feel like our struggles. This book is filled with so many memorable scenes that it was a joy to watch them weave into the shared memories of our own family.
I wasn’t sure if Little Women was too far about the heads of my 5 and 7-year-old, but they were warmly wrapped up in the story after the first few chapters. They each called out their favorite sisters and laughed aloud over the antics of Jo or Beth’s kittens. We read only the first part of the book (we’ll save the second, with its weddings—and funerals—for when they’re older), but already Little Women is a favorite in our home—not least because we now have our very own Josephine:

Little Women
Louisa May Alcott (1868)








stephanie says:
What a beauty! And a great response! My oldest is 12 (my other two girls are now 10 and 5 days away from 9) and we STILL haven’t read part 2. Mostly because I am not sure how I will get through it. : )
April 29, 2016 — 8:44 am
Thea Rosenburg says:
Oh, man, I don’t know how I’ll get through it either. With Kleenex handy and a glass of wine?
April 30, 2016 — 6:55 am
Stacy says:
Ah~ darling little Josephine. She is DELIGHTFUL.
Recently I found the perfect reply to one of the comments I hear every single time I venture out with my my five, and I found it on a little sign so I bought it: “If you think my hands are full, you should see my heart.”
But I adore your response, too— swiftly turning the conversation to a favorite BOOK? You’re a genius! 😉
~Stacy
April 29, 2016 — 10:11 am
Thea Rosenburg says:
Thank you, Stacy! “Delightful” is just the right word 🙂
I love that response! I get the “hands full” comment a lot, too, and tend to follow up with ” . . . of good things!” Especially when my kids are present. It drives me crazy when people say stuff like that in front of them, so any time we can put a positive spin on those comments, I go for it 🙂
April 30, 2016 — 6:55 am
Beth @ Pages and Margins says:
What a wonderful response to those comments! I love Little Women.
April 30, 2016 — 9:53 am
Thea Rosenburg says:
Thank you, Beth!
May 2, 2016 — 12:52 pm
Carolyn says:
Welcome back!
I love your answer! A book that features each type of family would be an amazing post! You could have Narnia for two boys two girls, The Railway Children for two girls and a boy… My kids love the picture book, This is My Home This is My School, in part because the genders and birth order of the kids reflect our own family!
So, it’s been ages since I’ve read Little Women, but I’m thinking about reading it to my kids. My oldest balks at anything she deems “lovey-lovey.” I can’t remember how much of that there is in the book… Do you think she’d be ok with it? Thanks!
April 30, 2016 — 10:24 am
Thea Rosenburg says:
Part Two of the book might be more lovey-dovey, but Part One is great because it’s told mostly from the perspective of Jo, who has absolutely no time for that kind of stuff 🙂
And what a great idea for a post! Maybe a “Find the Book That Fits Your Family” theme!
May 2, 2016 — 12:50 pm
Christina says:
Love Little Women! I also just watched a great documentary on Louisa May Alcott that was incredibly interesting. APPARENTLY writing for young people wasn’t her cup of tea and she just did it to pay the bills. Shocking! 😉 Still love Little Women, though. I think the idea of having 4 girls is awesome!
May 2, 2016 — 12:14 pm
Thea Rosenburg says:
. . . and yet she was so good at it! I think AA Milne has a similar story, though I’d have to double check that. I seem to remember that he was “really” a playwright (I have–but haven’t read–a murder mystery he wrote) and was a bit horrified that he was only known for Winnie-the-Pooh. Go figure!
May 2, 2016 — 12:52 pm
Jen Every Morning New Mercies says:
Yay! I’ve been waiting for this post! 🙂 I absolutely love Little Women. I think its because I grew up in a house of girls and truly cherish those memories. I’ve only seen the movie, so I’m really looking forward to reading this book with Jadyn! I know she will love it! We love and miss your family so much! Maybe the Lord will one day bring us back to the Pacific Northwest! 😉
Love, Jen
May 23, 2016 — 11:46 am
Thea Rosenburg says:
Oh, that would be so lovely 🙂 The book is beautiful–I think you’ll love it! Their mother is one of the best fictional mothers around.
September 23, 2016 — 1:47 pm