I have a confession to make: I read this book over a year ago, but even though it was lovely and completely worthy of a spot on this blog, I didn’t rush out and review it for you. I should have. The reasons I didn’t review it right away are hard to pin down, but they have something to do with the fact that it’s taken me over a year to realize that I just don’t know how to describe The Rise and Fall of Mount Majestic. The story is delightful, charming, and unlike anything else I’ve read, but I still don’t know how to describe it. I’m writing about it now because I can’t keep it from you any longer: you need to know about this book.
I’ll start with a summary, and perhaps that will get me warmed up: Persimmony Smudge (whose name is perfect, by the way) discovers a secret about the island where she lives and sets out to save her fellow islanders from certain doom. But Persimmony’s biggest obstacle isn’t a super villain with a diabolical scheme to take down the island government—it’s the islanders’ persistent refusal to believe that they are in any danger at all.
Persimmony stands up for the truth again and again, and I love that about her. She is ridiculed for believing something seemingly ludicrous by kings, peasants, loved ones, and strangers, but she is a determined heroine who does hard things no matter what it costs her. And the world she inhabits is quirky and worth saving, the sort of place that has new surprises tucked away in every cave and tunnel.
There! Now that I’ve taken a stab at describing the story, I feel a bit better, and it wasn’t as hard as I thought it would be. There’s still that undefinable magic to Jennifer Trafton’s story that I can’t pin down, but I do hope I’ve shared enough to inspire you to add this one to the top of your reading list. If you’re still on the fence, though, there’s this: the book is illustrated by Brett Helquist, one of my very favorite artists and illustrator of many extraordinary stories, the most notable of which is Lemony Snicket’s A Series of Unfortunate Events. You’re sold now, aren’t you?
The Rise and Fall of Mount Majestic
Jennifer Trafton (2011)
Jen Every Morning New Mercies says:
Yay! Another one to add to our wishlist!
May 23, 2016 — 11:34 am
Thea Rosenburg says:
Yes! And this one should go at or near the top of your list 🙂
June 30, 2016 — 7:04 am
Laure Hittle says:
i adore this book, and Jennifer, with my whole heart. i’ve never bought so many copies of anything in my life. So glad you reviewed it. 🙂
“A broom. A hat. A girl. A hole. Such small things in a big world.”
“Life is a mess and a miracle. So pick up a broom and dance.”
May 23, 2016 — 4:12 pm
Thea Rosenburg says:
And I am so glad you recommended it to me 🙂
June 30, 2016 — 7:04 am
Jamie Lamkin says:
You are right, it is a tough one to describe, but I have to thank you for inspiring us to read it in spite of its hard to pin down -ness. After reading your post here (having only recently discovered your blog) it shot to the top of our read-aloud pile, and we weren’t disappointed.
My kids and I had a great time with this delightfully peculiar tale. The fun Jennifer Trafton had with her word craft is evident, and there were many places in the story where we all had to pause and catch our breath from laughing. In no way did we find this discumbersomebubblating, though, and were able to pick up and continue merrily along after each outbreak. 🙂
Did you know she has a new book, Henry and the Chalk Dragon, due out in April of 2017? We can’t wait!
October 13, 2016 — 10:04 am
Thea Rosenburg says:
I’m so glad you liked this book! We, too, had to pause for laugh breaks. That is such a great problem to have with a read-aloud 🙂
I had heard about her new book and I am so excited to read it! And thank you so much for your comments–I have enjoyed each one of them immensely 🙂
October 15, 2016 — 3:19 pm